Cardinals Finally Pull the Plug on the Nolan Gorman Experiment
The St. Louis Cardinals are non-tendering infielder Nolan Gorman, letting the former 27-home-run hitter enter free agency after a disastrous 2026 season.
HotTakes Editorial TeamUpdated 1 min read
Finding live odds…

The St. Louis Cardinals are officially pulling the plug on the Nolan Gorman experiment, letting the former top prospect walk into free agency for absolutely nothing.
According to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, St. Louis is non-tendering the infielder ahead of Friday's 4 p.m. CT deadline. Instead of paying him through arbitration, the Cardinals are just opening the door and pointing toward the street.
"Joel Sherman of the New York Post reported the non-tender decision ahead of the deadline."
If you told a St. Louis fan in 2023 that Gorman would be cut loose for free, they would have checked your drink. He hit 27 home runs that year and looked like a middle-of-the-order fixture for the next decade.
Then the wheels completely fell off the wagon, rolled down a hill, and caught fire. Gorman spent 2026 hitting a brutal .184 with just nine home runs and a .580 OPS. He was so lost at the plate that the Cardinals had to demote him to Triple-A just to stop the bleeding.
That kind of statistical nosedive is hard to comprehend. Going from 27 bombs to a .184 average is not a slump. That is a witness protection program for a major league swing. Throw in a 2025 season interrupted by a hamstring strain, and the front office clearly decided they had seen enough.
There were rumors St. Louis tried to gauge trade interest at the deadline, but nobody is giving up real assets for a guy hitting under the Mendoza line. You cannot bluff the rest of the league when the numbers are printed right there on the scoreboard.
Now Gorman hits the open market as the ultimate reclamation project. If you are scanning the futures market for a comeback player lottery ticket, he fits the profile perfectly. Some front office is going to watch his 2023 tape, convince themselves their hitting coach is a miracle worker, and sign him to a cheap prove-it deal by next week.
Key stats
Hit 27 home runs in 2023
Batted .184 with a .580 OPS in 2026
Hit 9 home runs with 33 RBIs in 2026
What's next
Gorman will enter free agency where a team looking for cheap power will likely sign him to a prove-it deal.

Key stats



