The Colts Hit the Panic Button and Go Back to Anthony Richardson
Indianapolis is handing the starting quarterback job back to Anthony Richardson after a disastrous run with Daniel Jones sent the team tumbling down the AFC standings.
HotTakes Editorial TeamUpdated 1 min read
Finding live odds…

The Colts benching their franchise quarterback for Daniel Jones was already a fever dream, but going back to Anthony Richardson Sr. right as their season is collapsing is peak NFL comedy.
According to Ian Rapoport, Richardson is officially back as the starting quarterback for Indianapolis. This comes after a chaotic few months where the former fourth-overall pick was benched, shopped on the trade block, and sidelined by a fractured orbital bone from a freak equipment malfunction against the Arizona Cardinals.
"Ian Rapoport tweeted: '#Colts QB Anthony Richardson Sr. is the new starting QB.'"
The Colts handed Daniel Jones a one-year, $14 million deal to take over an offense that started the year 8-2. Since then, Indianapolis has completely face-planted. They just got blown out 26-3 by the Houston Texans, dropped to the sixth seed in the AFC, and surrendered their grip on the AFC South crown.
Before getting benched and injured, Richardson was a rollercoaster. In 11 starts in 2024, he threw 12 interceptions to just eight touchdowns, though he did add nearly 500 yards and six scores on the ground. His agent publicly called out the team's questionable trust earlier this year, which makes handing him the keys to a sinking ship feel less like a redemption arc and more like a panic button.
Going from Anthony Richardson to Daniel Jones and back to Anthony Richardson is like returning a pair of shoes because they gave you blisters, walking barefoot on hot asphalt for a month, and then begging the store for the shoes back.
Now Richardson has to salvage the season in a massive divisional game against the Jacksonville Jaguars this weekend. Bettors trying to handicap this offense are essentially throwing darts blindfolded right now. If Richardson can shake off the rust and the vision limitations, the Colts might save their playoff lives, but if he struggles, that Daniel Jones insurance policy is going to look even worse in hindsight.
Key stats
The Colts started the season 8-2 but have dropped to the 6th seed in the AFC.
Indianapolis recently lost 26-3 to the Houston Texans.
Daniel Jones was signed to a 1-year, $14 million deal in March.
In 11 starts in 2024, Richardson threw 12 interceptions and 8 touchdowns.
What's next
Richardson will start against the Jacksonville Jaguars this weekend as the Colts try to reclaim their spot in the AFC South and keep their playoff hopes alive.

Key stats



